← Reviewed games
Sun, January 29, 2017 · 2016-17

NYK @ ATL

NYK 139 — ATL 142
Calls reviewed
45
Graded incorrect
11
Officials
Curtis Blair, Scott Foster, Michael Smith

Q4

  • 0:01:57 Turnover: Traveling Not graded
    Carmelo Anthony

    [Observable in enhanced video] Anthony (NYK) moves his pivot foot.

  • 0:01:48 Foul: Offensive Correct call
    Carmelo Anthony on Paul Millsap

    Anthony (NYK) knocks away Millsap's (ATL) hand and affects his ability to defend.

  • 0:01:32 Foul: Offensive Correct non-call
    Dennis Schroder on Brandon Jennings

    Schroder (ATL) makes incidental contact with Jennings (NYK) that does not affect his ability to defend the play.

  • 0:01:30 Foul: Loose Ball Correct call
    Kristaps Porzingis on Dwight Howard

    Porzingis (NYK) clamps the arm of Howard (ATL), affecting his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:01:17 Foul: Personal Correct call
    Paul Millsap on Brandon Jennings

    Millsap (ATL) makes body to body contact with Jennings (NYK) that affects his SQBR.

  • 0:01:11 Foul: Offensive Incorrect non-call
    Joakim Noah on Dennis Schroder

    Noah (NYK) sets the screen on Schroder (ATL) and does not give him room to avoid the contact.

  • 0:01:07 Turnover: Traveling Not graded
    Carmelo Anthony

    [Observable in enhanced video] Anthony (NYK) moves his pivot foot.

  • 0:00:54.800000 Foul: Loose Ball Incorrect non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Dwight Howard

    Anthony (NYK) dislodges Howard (ATL) affecting his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:00:49.600000 Turnover: Traveling Not graded
    Dennis Schroder

    [Observable in enhanced video] Schroder (ATL) moves his pivot foot.

  • 0:00:30.200000 Foul: Loose Ball Incorrect non-call
    Dennis Schroder on Joakim Noah

    Schroder (ATL) clamps the arm of Noah (NYK) and affects his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:00:15.400000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Anthony (NYK) maintains legal guarding position and makes incidental contact with Hardaway Jr. (ATL) that does not affect his drive to the basket and shot attempt.

  • 0:00:10.200000 Foul: Personal Correct call
    Courtney Lee on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Lee (NYK) commits a take foul on Hardaway Jr. (ATL).

  • 0:00:10.200000 Foul: Loose Ball Correct non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Mike Muscala

    Anthony (NYK) and Muscala (ATL) briefly engage and separate during rebounding.

  • 0:00:09.900000 Violation: Kicked Ball Correct call
    Kent Bazemore

    Bazemore (ATL) intentionally kicks the ball on the play.

  • 0:00:03.500000 Foul: Shooting Incorrect non-call
    Paul Millsap on Carmelo Anthony

    Millsap (ATL) makes contact to the body of Anthony (NYK) that affects his SQBR on the driving shot attempt.

  • 0:00:01.400000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Paul Millsap

    Anthony (NYK) maintains legal guarding position as he defends Millsap's (ATL) shot attempt.

Q5

  • 0:01:56 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Anthony (NYK) legally contests Hardaway Jr.'s (ATL) jump shot attempt. Any "high-five" contact after the release is considered incidental.

  • 0:01:14 Foul: Defense 3 Second Incorrect non-call
    Dwight Howard

    Howard (ATL) is in the paint without actively guarding an opponent for longer than three seconds.

  • 0:01:12 Foul: Offensive Correct non-call
    Carmelo Anthony on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Anthony (NYK) sets the screen on Hardaway Jr. (ATL) and gives him room to avoid the contact.

  • 0:00:53.600000 Foul: Loose Ball Correct call
    Carmelo Anthony on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Anthony (NYK) dislodges Hardaway Jr. (ATL), affecting his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:00:53.600000 Foul: Loose Ball Not graded
    Justin Holiday on Dwight Howard

    [Incidental or immaterial] LHH shows Holiday (NYK) clamps the arm of Howard (ATL) and affects his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:00:53.600000 Foul: Shooting Incorrect call
    Joakim Noah on Dwight Howard

    Noah (NYK) makes contact with Howard's (ATL) arm that affects his SQBR, but the foul is prior to Howard gaining possession of the ball and entering his shooting motion. INC

  • 0:00:35.200000 Turnover: Traveling Not graded

    Anthony (NYK) switches pivot feet on the perimeter. CNC

  • 0:00:33.500000 Foul: Loose Ball Not graded
    Joakim Noah

    Noah (NYK) and Howard (ATL) briefly engage and separate during rebounding. CC

  • 0:00:32.100000 Instant Replay: Support Ruling Not graded

    After communicating with the Replay Center, the ruling on the floor of a jump ball stands. Video

  • 0:00:11 Foul: Defense 3 Second Not graded

    [Incidental or immaterial] Bazemore (ATL) is in the paint without actively guarding an opponent for longer than three seconds. CNC

  • 0:00:06.900000 Foul: Away from Play Not graded
    Carmelo Anthony

    Anthony (NYK) makes incidental contact with Millsap (ATL) that does not affect his FOM off ball. CNC

  • 0:00:01.500000 Foul: Shooting Not graded
    Joakim Noah

    Noah (NYK) maintains legal guarding position and makes incidental contact with Howard (ATL) that does not affect his shot attempt. CC

Q6

  • 0:01:37 Foul: Personal Not graded
    Brandon Jennings

    Jennings (NYK) makes body to body contact with Millsap (ATL) that affects his SQBR.

  • 0:01:18 Foul: Personal Correct non-call
    Paul Millsap on Carmelo Anthony

    Millsap (ATL) makes incidental contact with Anthony (NYK) that does not affect his SQBR.

  • 0:01:05 Foul: Personal Correct non-call
    Joakim Noah on Paul Millsap

    Noah (NYK) makes incidental contact with Millsap (ATL) that does not affect his FOM off ball.

  • 0:01:00 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Joakim Noah on Paul Millsap

    Noah (NYK) legally contests Millsap's (ATL) jump shot attempt. Any "high-five" contact after the release is considered incidental.

  • 0:00:37 Turnover: Traveling Not graded
    Carmelo Anthony on Kent Bazemore

    [Observable in enhanced video] Anthony (NYK) moves his pivot foot.

  • 0:00:12.900000 Violation: Lane Not graded
    Brandon Jennings

    [Incidental or immaterial] Jennings (NYK) enters the area inside the three-point line prior to the free throw being released.

  • 0:00:12.900000 Foul: Shooting Incorrect call
    Carmelo Anthony on Dennis Schroder

    Anthony (NYK) makes marginal contact with Schroder (ATL) that does not affect his drive to the basket and shot attempt.

  • 0:00:12.300000 Foul: Away from Play Correct non-call
    Tim Hardaway Jr. on Mindaugas Kuzminskas

    Hardaway Jr. (ATL) makes incidental contact with Kuzminskas (NYK) that does not affect his FOM off ball.

  • 0:00:11.600000 Foul: Personal Correct call
    Paul Millsap on Brandon Jennings

    Millsap (ATL) makes contact with Jennings (NYK) that affects his SQBR.

  • 0:00:01.500000 Violation: Kicked Ball Correct non-call
    Mindaugas Kuzminskas on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Kuzminskas (NYK) does not intentionally kick the ball on the play.

  • 0:00:00.600000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Courtney Lee on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Lee (NYK) cleanly blocks Hardaway's (ATL) shot attempt.

Q7

  • 0:01:00 Foul: Personal Correct call
    Courtney Lee on Kent Bazemore

    Lee (NYK) makes contact with Bazemore (ATL) that affects his SQBR.

  • 0:00:53.100000 Foul: Personal Correct non-call
    Justin Holiday on Paul Millsap

    Holiday (NYK) makes incidental contact with Millsap (ATL) that does not affect Millsap's FOM off ball.

  • 0:00:47.300000 Instant Replay: Support Ruling Correct call

    After communicating with the Replay Center, the ruling on the floor that Schroder's (ATL) field goal attempt hit the rim is confirmed.

  • 0:00:36.100000 Foul: Offensive Not graded
    Paul Millsap on Brandon Jennings

    [Incidental or immaterial] Millsap (ATL) puts a hand into Jennings' (NYK) back and affects his ability to defend.

  • 0:00:31.800000 Foul: Loose Ball Correct non-call
    Mindaugas Kuzminskas on Mike Muscala

    Kuzminskas (NYK) and Muscala (ATL) make incidental contact with one another during rebounding.

  • 0:00:09.600000 Foul: Shooting Correct call
    Tim Hardaway Jr. on Courtney Lee

    Hardaway Jr. (ATL) makes contact with Lee's (NYK) body that affects his jump shot attempt.

  • 0:00:04.400000 Foul: Shooting Incorrect non-call
    Justin Holiday on Dennis Schroder

    Holiday (NYK) makes contact with Schroder's (ATL) body that affects his drive to the basket and shot attempt.

  • 0:00:01.400000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Tim Hardaway Jr. on Courtney Lee

    Hardaway Jr. (ATL) makes marginal contact with Lee (NYK) and does not take away his landing space. Lee makes incidental contact with Hardaway Jr. during his shooting motion.

Q8

  • 0:01:46 Foul: Loose Ball Correct non-call
    Malcolm Delaney on Kyle O'Quinn

    Delaney (ATL) and O'Quinn (NYK) briefly engage and separate during rebounding.

  • 0:01:26 Foul: Shooting Incorrect non-call
    Malcolm Delaney on Brandon Jennings

    Delaney (ATL) makes contact with Jennings' (NYK) body that affects his drive to the basket and shot attempt.

  • 0:01:23 Foul: Loose Ball Correct call
    Kyle O'Quinn on Mike Muscala

    O'Quinn (NYK) dislodges Muscala (ATL), affecting his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:01:17 Foul: Offensive Correct non-call
    Mike Muscala on Mindaugas Kuzminskas

    Muscala (ATL) sets the screen on Kuzminskas (NYK) and gives him room to avoid the contact.

  • 0:01:14 Foul: Loose Ball Not graded
    Willy Hernangomez on Mike Muscala

    [Incidental or immaterial] Hernangomez (NYK) grabs Muscala's (ATL) jersey during rebounding.

  • 0:01:14 Foul: Shooting Correct call
    Kyle O'Quinn on Paul Millsap

    O'Quinn (NYK) makes contact with Millsap's (ATL) body that affects his driving shot attempt.

  • 0:00:49.800000 Foul: Personal Correct non-call
    Paul Millsap on Mindaugas Kuzminskas

    Millsap (ATL) makes incidental contact with Kuzminskas (NYK) that does not affect his SQBR.

  • 0:00:45.400000 Turnover: 24 Second Violation Correct call

    Correctly called 24 second violation.

  • 0:00:31.600000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Willy Hernangomez on Tim Hardaway Jr.

    Hernangomez (NYK) obtains a legal guarding position and jumps vertically as he contests Hardaway Jr.'s (ATL) driving shot attempt.

  • 0:00:20.200000 Turnover: Traveling Not graded
    Courtney Lee

    [Observable in enhanced video] Lee (NYK) moves his pivot foot.

  • 0:00:10.200000 Foul: Personal Correct call
    Willy Hernangomez on Dennis Schroder

    Hernangomez (NYK) commits a take foul on Schroder (ATL).

  • 0:00:10.200000 Foul: Loose Ball Incorrect non-call
    Mindaugas Kuzminskas on Mike Muscala

    Kuzminskas (NYK) faces up with Muscala (ATL) and affects his ability to retrieve the rebound.

  • 0:00:06.700000 Foul: Shooting Correct non-call
    Paul Millsap on Courtney Lee

    Millsap (ATL) legally contests Lee's (NYK) jump shot attempt. Any "high-five" contact after the release is considered incidental.

  • 0:00:05.400000 Foul: Loose Ball Incorrect non-call
    Mike Muscala on Willy Hernangomez

    Muscala (ATL) clamps the arm of Hernangomez (NYK) and affects his ability to retrieve the rebound.

Verdicts and comments are the NBA's, published in its Last Two Minute Report. Only games within three points at the two-minute mark are reviewed, so this is officiating under maximum scrutiny rather than a sample of officiating generally.

Independent, non-commercial project for analysis and education — not affiliated with or endorsed by the NBA. Data from public NBA releases (pr.nba.com), tabulated by Ernst & Young. Source ↗